登陆注册
34933700000010

第10章

Equally in the writings of Plato and in those of not a few living men ofscience, we find it assumed that there is an analogy between the processof creation and the process of manufacture. Now not only is this conceptionone which cannot by any cumulative process of thought, or the fulfilmentof predictions based on it, be shown to answer to anything actual; but itcannot be mentally realized, even when all its assumptions are granted. Thoughthe proceedings of a human artificer may vaguely symbolize a method afterwhich the Universe might be shaped, yet imagination of this method does nothelp us to solve the ultimate problem; namely, the origin of the materialsof which the Universe consists. The artizan does not make the iron, wood,or stone, he uses, but merely fashions and combines them. If we suppose suns,and planets, and satellites, and all they contain to have been similarlyformed by a "Great Artificer," we suppose merely that certain pre-existingelements were thus put into their present arrangement. But whence the pre-existingelements? The production of matter out of nothing is the real mystery whichneither this simile nor any other enables us to conceive; and a simile whichdoes not enable us to conceive this may as well be dispensed with. Stillmore manifest becomes the insufficiency of this theory of things, when weturn from material objects to that which contains them -- when instead ofmatter we contemplate space. Did there exist nothing but an immeasurablevoid, explanation would be needed as much as it is now. There would stillarise the question -- how came it so? If the theory of creation by externalagency were an adequate one, it would supply an answer; and its answer wouldbe -- space was made in the same manner that matter was made. But the impossibilityof conceiving this is so manifest that no one dares to assert it. For ifspace was created it must have been previously non-existent. The non-existenceof space cannot, however, by any mental effort be imagined. And if the non-existenceof space is absolutely inconceivable, then, necessarily, its creation isabsolutely inconceivable. Lastly, even supposing that the genesis of theUniverse could really be represented in thought as due to an external agency,the mystery would be as great as ever; for there would still arise the question-- how came there to be an external agency? To account for this only thesame three hypotheses are possible -- self-existence, self-creation, andcreation by external agency. Of these the last is useless: it commits usto an infinite series of such agencies, and even then leaves us where wewere. By the second we are led into the same predicament; since, as alreadyshown, self-creation implies an infinite series of potential existences.

We are obliged, therefore, to fall back on the first, which is the one commonlyaccepted and commonly supposed to be satisfactory. Those who cannot conceivea self-existent Universe, and therefore assume a creator as the source ofthe Universe, take for granted that they can conceive a self-existent Creator.

The mystery which they recognize in this great fact surrounding them on everyside, they transfer to an alleged source of this great fact, and then supposethat they have solved the mystery. But they delude themselves. As was provedat the outset of the argument, self-existence is inconceivable; and thisholds true whatever be the nature of the object of which it is predicated.

Whoever agrees that the atheistic hypothesis is untenable because it involvesthe impossible idea of self-existence, must perforce admit that the theistichypothesis is untenable if it contains the same impossible idea.

Thus these three different suppositions, verbally intelligible thoughthey are, and severally seeming to their respective adherents quite rational,turn out, when critically examined, to be literally unthinkable. It is nota question of probability, or credibility, but of conceivability. Experimentproves that the elements of these hypotheses cannot even be put togetherin consciousness; and we can entertain them only as we entertain such pseud-ideasas a square fluid and a moral substance -- only by abstaining from the endeavourto render them into actual thoughts. Or, reverting to our original mode ofstatement, we may say that they severally involve symbolic conceptions ofthe illegitimate and illusive kind. Differing so widely as they seem to do,the atheistic, the pantheistic, and the theistic hypotheses contain the sameultimate element. It is impossible to avoid ****** the assumption of self-existencesomewhere; and whether that assumption be made nakedly or under complicateddisguises, it is equally vicious, equally unthinkable. Be it a fragment ofmatter, or some fancied potential form of matter, or some more remote andstill less imaginable mode of being, our conception of its self-existencecan be framed only by joining with it the notion of unlimited duration throughpast time. And as unlimited duration is inconceivable, all those formal ideasinto which it enters are inconceivable; and indeed, if such an expressionis allowable, are the more inconceivable in proportion as the other elementsof the ideas are indefinite. So that in fact, impossible as it is to thinkof the actual Universe as self-existing, we do but multiply impossibilitiesof thought by every attempt we make to explain its existence. §12. If from the origin of the Universe we turn to its nature, thelike insurmountable difficulties rise up before us on all sides -- or rather,the same difficulties under new aspects. We find ourselves obliged to makecertain assumptions; and yet we find these assumptions cannot be representedin thought.

同类推荐
  • Hell Fer Sartain

    Hell Fer Sartain

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 佛说弥勒菩萨上生兜率天经

    佛说弥勒菩萨上生兜率天经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 孟子私淑录

    孟子私淑录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 谤佛经

    谤佛经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 徐氏家谱

    徐氏家谱

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 狠妃

    狠妃

    尼玛,这是什么情况?前一刻刚得知男友背叛,后一刻穿越时空被男人殴打!浑身无力,满身是伤。可她是谁?现代杀手炽天使,想跟她斗?管你是什么王爷,皇子,妖孽在世,本王妃就同你过过招!可为毛她还没出手,就有一堆男人抢着要替她出头?
  • 诉情殇:秋枫红叶人不归

    诉情殇:秋枫红叶人不归

    你是我睡梦惊醒的幻想,我为你等待千年,却还是触摸不到你,就让我一直一直守护你。如果开始就是个美丽的错误,那就让它一直错下去,谁也阻挡不住我们在一起的脚步。
  • 诛天九霄

    诛天九霄

    我存于混乱之际,友亲亦我存之意。友亲固有尔背叛,是我所不能容之。天地浩劫两大界,我欲持剑断天下。我欲封天下之王,手持诸神战为王。
  • 娱乐圈:美男凶猛

    娱乐圈:美男凶猛

    千万别小看了明星经纪人这一特殊生物。凶悍起来,文能智斗狗仔,武能逼退流氓。身前一堆美男,身后一堆狗仔。她该如何应付?嗨,美男如狼,煞是凶猛。
  • 没想到我才是幕后黑手吧

    没想到我才是幕后黑手吧

    秦桥修炼前的想法:年薪千万,豪车别墅,装X打脸,四方拜服。秦桥修炼后的现实:负债千万,居无定所,装X不成,都想杀我。
  • 天行

    天行

    号称“北辰骑神”的天才玩家以自创的“牧马冲锋流”战术击败了国服第一弓手北冥雪,被誉为天纵战榜第一骑士的他,却受到小人排挤,最终离开了效力已久的银狐俱乐部。是沉沦,还是再次崛起?恰逢其时,月恒集团第四款游戏“天行”正式上线,虚拟世界再起风云!
  • 快穿白月光攻略

    快穿白月光攻略

    【没心没肺貌美白月光×深情专一舔狗前男友】1v1,甜宠虐渣向盛卿,在天界是一个知名人物。并非因为她是帝姬,她名动三界的盛世美颜,她所传承的强大神力,而因为她居然甩了万千少女的梦中情人君珩上神!两人的cp粉天天盼他们复合。盛卿:不好意思了各位,老娘不吃回头草。后来:真香。————————————————“经检验,笔下三千世界中最适合您的身份是白月光,已为您绑定白月光系统。”盛卿带着对帅哥的兴趣进了笔下三千世界开始历练。不知后头还跟了一个得知消息匆匆赶过来的男人:“让我进去。”“等等,经检验,笔下三千世界最适合您的身份是...隐形深情舔狗,您确定要进去吗?”“去,和盛卿去同一个。”“好...”的呢。你怎么就蹦进去了呢我话还没说完呢!你已经历练过了进去之后记忆也会没有的啊!不过为什么清冷高傲战斗力max的君珩上神会是隐形的深情舔狗?突然觉得自己知道了什么不得了的事情!
  • 四小阴门

    四小阴门

    四门世代相传的古老职业,几代人光怪陆离的传奇人生。过阴山,闯尸岭,这一切的背后,到底暗藏着怎样不为人知秘密?探寻几大集凶之地,勇闯阴煞怪异的鬼林,恐怖离奇的遭遇,九死一生的经历,他们到底在寻找着什么?他们又能否成功?重重迷雾,步步惊心,这四小阴门,几大家族,又有什么不为人知的地方?
  • 谁的苹果

    谁的苹果

    珍惜眼前人,失去的不会再回来,即使回来也已经改变,抓住了千万别放手,因为下面也许是深渊……
  • 临天巅峰

    临天巅峰

    上一世吾未能承载天命,这一生必将斩尽仇敌,承天命,踏天路。神挡杀神,佛挡杀佛。随心所欲,无能拘束。吾欲凌天,傲于世间。吾必凌于天主角的机缘通通抢,主角的法宝通通收。