登陆注册
34933700000001

第1章

Religion and Science §1. We too often forget that not only is there "a soul of goodnessin things evil," but very generally also, a soul of truth in thingserroneous. While many admit the abstract probability that a falsity has usuallya nucleus of verity, few bear this abstract probability in mind, when passingjudgment on the options of others. A belief that is proved to be grosslyat variance with fact, is cast aside with indignation or contempt; and inthe heat of antagonism scarcely any one inquires what there was in this beliefwhich commended it to men's minds. Yet there must have been something. Andthere is reason to suspect that this something was its correspondence withcertain of their experiences: an extremely limited or vague correspondenceperhaps, but still, a correspondence. Even the absurdest report may in nearlyevery instance be traced to an actual occurrence; and had there been no suchactual occurrence, this preposterous misrepresentation of it would neverhave existed. Though the distorted or magnified image transmitted to us throughthe refracting medium of rumour, is utterly unlike the reality; yet in theabsence of the reality there would have been no distorted or magnified image.

And thus it is with human beliefs in general. Entirely wrong as they mayappear, the implication is that they originally contained, and perhaps stillcontain, some small amount of truth.

Definite views on this matter would be very useful to us. It is importantthat we should form something like a general theory of current options, sothat we may neither over-estimate nor under-estimate their worth. Arrivingat correct judgments on disputed questions, much depends on the mental attitudepreserved while listening to, or taking part in, the controversies; and forthe preservation of a right attitude, it is needful that we should learnhow true, and yet how untrue, are average human beliefs. On the one hand,we must keep free from that bias in favour of received ideas which expressesitself in such dogmas as "What every one says must be true," or"The voice of the people is the voice of God." On the other hand,the fact disclosed by a survey of the past that majorities have usually beenwrong, must not blind us to the complementary fact that majorities have usuallynot been entirely wrong. And the avoidance of these extremes being a pre-requisiteto catholic thinking, we shall do well to provide ourselves with a safeguardagainst them, by ****** a valuation of opinions in the abstract. To thisend we must contemplate the kind of relation that ordinarily subsists betweenopinions and facts. Let us do so with one of those beliefs which under variousforms has prevailed among all nations in all times. §2. Early traditions represent rulers as gods or demigods. By theirsubjects, primitive kings were regarded as superhuman in origin and superhumanin power. They possessed divine titles, received obeisances like those madebefore the altars of deities, and were in some cases actually worshipped.

Of course along with the implied beliefs there existed a belief in the unlimitedpower of the ruler over his subjects, extending even to the taking of theirlives at will; as until recently in Fiji, where a victim stood unbound tobe killed at the word of his chief himself declaring, "whatever theking says must be done."

In other times and among other races, we find these beliefs a little modified.

The monarch, instead of being thought god or demigod, is conceived to bea man having divine authority, with perhaps more or less of divine nature.

He retains, however, titles expressing his heavenly descent or relationships,and is still saluted in forms and words as humble as those addressed to theDeity. While in some places the lives and properties of his people, if notso completely at his mercy, are still in theory supposed to be his.

Later in the progress of civilization, as during the middle ages in Europe,the current opinions respecting the relationship of rulers and ruled arefurther changed. For the theory of divine origin there is substituted thatof divine right. No longer god or demigod, or even god-descended, the kingis now regarded simply as God's vicegerent. The obeisances made to him arenot so extreme in their humility; and his sacred titles lose much of theirmeaning. Moreover his authority ceases to be unlimited. Subjects deny hisright to dispose at will of their lives and properties, and yield allegianceonly in the shape of obedience to his commands.

With advancing political option has come still greater restriction ofmonarchical power. Belief in the supernatural character of the ruler, longago repudiated by ourselves for example, has left behind it nothing morethan the popular tendency to ascribe unusual goodness, wisdom, and beautyto the monarch. Loyalty, which originally meant implicit submission to theking's will, now means a merely nominal profession of subordination, andthe fulfilment of certain forms of respect. By deposing some and puttingothers in their places, we have not only denied the divine rights of certainmen to rule, but we have denied that they have any rights beyond those originatingin the assent of the nation. Though our forms of speech and our State-documentsstill assert the subjection of the citizens to the ruler, our actual beliefsand our daily proceedings implicitly assert the contrary. We have entirelydivested the monarch of legislative power, and should immediately rebel againsthis or her dictation even in matters of small concern.

Nor has the rejection of primitive political beliefs resulted only intransferring the power of a autocrat to a representative body. The viewsheld respecting governments in general, of whatever form, are now widelydifferent from those once held. Whether popular or despotic, governmentsin ancient times were supposed to have unlimited authority over their subjects.

同类推荐
  • 庄氏史案

    庄氏史案

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 佛说摩登女解形中六事经

    佛说摩登女解形中六事经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • FRECKLES

    FRECKLES

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 王氏谈録

    王氏谈録

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 宫观碑志

    宫观碑志

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 朱雀翎

    朱雀翎

    三皇五帝,九大圣庭,十方天界一个身负离奇身世的神秘少年,自凡尘中强势崛起,一路倾城红颜相伴,一路天罚地劫随行……命中注定的劫数,是听天由命,还是逆而伐天?
  • 修真从练习生开始

    修真从练习生开始

    吕元有一次投放兼职简历,无意中被修真界的人招聘过去,当任人间的练习生,负责执行各种奇葩任务,每次执行任务都有一个雇主加他的微信,全都是一些昵称古里古怪的人。慢慢的,他的三观完全奔踏了!
  • 我这20几年

    我这20几年

    一个普普通通留守长大的普通人,用文笔稍微记录下自己的这20来年
  • 灿陵武动

    灿陵武动

    一道光笀滑过天际,带来无限战争。何时能终结?命里注定少年出世,大陆神话来临。传奇何时现?
  • TFBOYS之我的人是你

    TFBOYS之我的人是你

    这个作品是由TFBOYS和3个女生的爱情故事
  • 谁的青春无遗憾

    谁的青春无遗憾

    谨以此书,纪念那个即将逝去的青春,还有她。一个懵懂无知的少年,遇到了那个让他心动一辈子的她。面对未知的未来,这名少年的青春开始了……
  • 给依依的一封信

    给依依的一封信

    最近看了村上春树的作品以及他的一些经历,莫名其妙的就想写作,但一直迟迟没有动笔,不知道写什么好,今天终于有了想法,直接给你写封信吧,希望你长大后你读完能给你带来不一样的感受,从中能吸收有用的信息和知识!
  • 魂断成吉思汗陵

    魂断成吉思汗陵

    【起点第五编辑组签约作品】处于社会底层的楚洋与胖子在一个地窖中偶然发现了七百多年前全真教弟子死前遗留的一份血书,因此牵扯出一个惊天的秘密.当今最大秘密-成吉思汗陵,将在此拉开神秘的帷幕……寻宝、探险、与巫术血淋淋的对决……贯穿全书的将会是一条惊悚与刺激的长练。而在无数意想不到、突如其来的情节中当然还间杂着楚洋与几位美女的感情纠葛,希望引领大家进入一个从所未见的神奇世界。(即将恢复更新!)______________________________本书QQ号251267701欢迎兄弟们指教感谢衰衰哥提供本书QQ群号32652880感谢水丁提供封面设计本书寻求出版渠道,有意者加QQ不诚勿扰
  • 炉石末日世界

    炉石末日世界

    在一次机缘巧合之下,地球世界与炉石世界连接。满城的恶魔在肆虐,鱼人布满了沿海的地区,兽人、死灵、魔法、诅咒,一切超出科学解释的事物出现。在这个世界,人们是驱逐异界生物恢复地球昔日盛况,还是与这些生物在地球展开新的平衡?
  • 山上有座佛学院

    山上有座佛学院

    这个世界的和尚,脑子有问题,开了间佛宗学院,教魔头改邪归正,积德行善。